Skip to main content

Do We Need Cities in a Country of Remote Workers?

Jan 14 2021 • 3 min read

Recently there have been several reports about people moving out of cities and into the countryside. This apparent urban exodus, prompted in part by the mass move to online working, raises two questions: What are cities for? And can their function be replicated by people working and living remotely?

Researchers from a wide range of backgrounds have established that cities fulfil multiple roles. But one theme that consistently appears is their role in generating social interactions.

In short, cities provide an environment for people and ideas to come together. And the bigger the city, the more interactions they create.

As the graph below illustrates, this is because the number of links between individual members of a group scales exponentially as group size increases. And the same dynamic plays out on a larger scale in urban environments: as a city’s population grows, the number of possible social interactions within its walls rapidly increases.

From the chaotic randomness of these social encounters emerges a surprisingly ordered set of outputs. For it is not just the number of social interactions that increases exponentially as urban populations grow: income, wealth, and innovation (as measured by patent production) all do exactly the same. And, up to a limit, so does average pedestrian walking speed.

Remarkably, these socioeconomic phenomena all scale predictably with an exponent of around 1.15. In other words, when a city population doubles (or grows by 100%) these quantities typically increase by around 115%.

This is called superlinear scaling, and is simply a product of the increase in individual social interactions – an increase that is difficult to reproduce in an online environment, as anyone who has experienced a populous video call will know.

At the same time, the energy and infrastructure requirements of a growing urban population also scale exponentially. But in contrast to the above, the exponent for quantities such as the length of roads, water pipes, and electrical lines is around 0.85.

This is known as sublinear scaling, and means that each doubling of population size results in a systematic efficiency saving of 15% – so as cities grow, they do more with less.

These patterns appear predictably within almost every country from Chile to China – a phenomenon known as the ‘universality of urban scaling’. In practice, this means that if someone tells you the population of a certain city, by looking at other cities within the same country you can predict quantities such as the number of petrol stations and patents produced with around 85% accuracy.

These findings explain one of the most important functions of cities: they create serendipitous social interactions and reliably convert them into new ideas, opportunities, and possibilities.

In addition, this research explains why the countryside grass may have looked greener to city-dwellers during the pandemic. Starved of its vital ingredient of social interaction, the city’s capacity to generate valuable social and economic output is severely inhibited.

All of this suggests that once lockdowns are lifted, cities are unlikely to be dethroned by the collective shift to remote working. For all the merits of video conferencing and other social technologies, in their current form they struggle to generate the chance combinations of people and ideas upon which human creativity and invention so often depend.

For now at least, you need a city for that.

Read recommended blogs

Automatic Enrolment: A New Application in Savings Automatic Enrolment: A New Application in Savings

One of the most cited applications of behavioural science in practice is the powerful effect of automatically enrolling people into schemes like pension plans. With a simple change in the sign-up process, these interventions show that we can move from a world in which the minority of people save for retirement to one in which...

Jan 8 2024 • 3 min read

Jan 8 2024 • 3 min read

New Year, Same Old Predictions New Year, Same Old Predictions

At the beginning of a New Year, financial journalists churn out articles about how the markets are likely to perform over the next 12 months. Their sources are often the forecasts published by industry analysts. According to one report published in December 2023, for example, analysts have on average predicted that the value of the...

Jan 3 2024 • 3 min read

Jan 3 2024 • 3 min read

What Could Your Partner Do To Improve Your Relationship? What Could Your Partner Do To Improve Your Relationship?

If you’ve ever been in a long-term relationship, there’s a good chance you’ll be able to think of a few things your partner could do (or could have done) to improve the relationship. Perhaps they could listen more, for example, or be more attentive? At CogCo, we wanted to see whether our new platform –...

Sep 20 2023 • 3 min read

Sep 20 2023 • 3 min read

Interested in working with us?

Get in touch at info@cogco.co

Copied to clipboard