Skip to main content

What Do 19th Century Farmers Tell Us About Smartphone Notifications?

Jul 28 2022 • 3 min read

Imagine that you are a 19th century cattle farmer whose herd grazes on common land shared by many other farmers (and many other cows).

You are trying to decide whether to add one more cow to your herd. On the positive side, an extra animal would bring you additional income. On the negative side, another cow means the common land must bear the burden of another mouth to feed.

What do you do?

This particular scenario was popularised by the American ecologist Garrett Hardin in 1968. Hardin concluded that farmers would generally choose to take on another cow because the benefits of the additional income go directly to the farmer; while the costs of overgrazing are shared between all the farmers.

The result is a ‘tragedy of the commons’ whereby each farmer has an incentive to add another cow…and another…and another…until the land has nothing left to give, and everyone is worse off than they would have been if they had all decided to stick with their original lot.

The tragedy of the commons is a concept that has been used by researchers for several decades to understand the management of many limited common resources, from forests to fisheries. But it turns out that it can also help us think about a more personal resource: our attention.

At first glance, our individual attention might seem very different to the collective commons. But our attention is similarly a limited resource that, in today’s world, is being grazed upon by multiple apps and websites (the 21st century equivalent of our 19th century farmers).

One particularly popular grazing tool is the smartphone notification. Recent surveys indicate that around half of adults in the US feel that they receive too many notifications; and around half of adults in the UK say that without their phone they would feel more focused and pay more attention to the world around them. These findings suggest that, just as overgrazing depletes the commons, notifications deplete and dissipate our attention.

What Hardin’s metaphor helps us to understand is why organisations (farmers) feel compelled to send us more and more notifications (take on more cows). The reason lies in a similar asymmetry between the benefits and costs of doing so.

The only organisation that derives a benefit from sending a notification, for instance, is the one that sends it. On the other hand, the costs – such as an overwhelmed or interrupted recipient who is more likely to ignore further notifications – tend to be shared by all of the organisations vying for our attention. And so, as a result of this asymmetry, we receive another notification…and another…and another.

Following the publication of his famous paper in 1968, Hardin emphasised two points. First, that the decisions of greedy farmers harm both the farming community and themselves in the long run. And second, that tragedies are much more likely to occur in unmanaged commons.

His lessons for notification senders and recipients alike are, we hope, clear enough.

Read recommended blogs

What Does the Virtual Property Market Tell us About the Psychology of Ownership? What Does the Virtual Property Market Tell us About the Psychology of Ownership?

How much would you pay for a virtual property? Not one of those ones made of bricks and mortar, but a digital one made of pixels that exists only in the virtual world. If your answer is around £375,000, then you have something in common with the person who recently purchased Mars House – a...

Mar 28 2022 • 3 min read

Mar 28 2022 • 3 min read

What’s in a Name? How Naming Something Changes the Way We Think About It What’s in a Name? How Naming Something Changes the Way We Think About It

Have you ever wondered why so many peoples across the world and through the ages have decided that they need a God of Thunder or Lightning? Be it Thor in Norse mythology, Zeus in Ancient Greece, Vajrapani in Buddhism, or Indra in Hinduism, the gods of extreme weather often play a particularly powerful and prominent...

Feb 22 2022 • 3 min read

Feb 22 2022 • 3 min read

Great Expectations: Comets, Cures, and Culture Great Expectations: Comets, Cures, and Culture

Adam McKay’s latest film, Don’t Look Up, tells the story of our response to a comet heading directly for Earth. One of the film’s main storylines is the battle between two tribes: those who believe in the threat posed by the comet, and those who do not. In the end, these contrasting beliefs both become...

Feb 11 2022 • 3 min read

Feb 11 2022 • 3 min read

Interested in working with us?

Get in touch at info@cogco.co

Copied to clipboard